Summary
- One Piece’s success ended a disappointing pattern of live-action anime variations on Netflix.
- One Piece season 1 was well-received with a excessive critic rating, and season 2 is going on
- Knights of the Zodiac served as a reminder of the challenges in adapting anime to live-action.
One Piece season 1 was successful for Netflix, however its success made us all neglect a distinct live-action adaptation that proved adapting anime stays very troublesome. One Piece gladly put an finish to a disappointing Netflix live-action anime adaptation pattern. With an 85% Rotten Tomatoes critic rating and having charmed each long-time One Piece followers and new viewers, One Piece was one of Netflix’s most-watched shows of 2023. It isn’t any shock that One Piece season 2 is going on, with the sequence possible persevering with for a number of years.
I’m very enthusiastic about the way forward for One Piece on Netflix. Although it is extremely troublesome to think about how the sequence plans to cowl greater than 20 years’ price of tales, One Piece season 1 satisfied me that the sequence has what it takes to sort out all the opposite arcs which might be but to come back. Unfortunately, not each beloved anime property has gotten the “One Piece treatment” in relation to live-action variations.
Related
I Thought Nothing Could Be Worse Than Dragonball Evolution Until This 2023 Live-Action Movie Proved Me Wrong
Dragonball Evolution was the worst live-action anime adaptation of all time for over a decade, however a 2023 movie was sadly simply as dangerous, if not worse.
Knights Of The Zodiac Was Released 4 Months Before One Piece Live-Action
2023 Saw Two Very Different Live-Action Anime Adaptations
Knights of the Zodiac
2.5
Knights of the Zodiac is a 2023 fantasy film primarily based on Masami Kurumada’s manga titled Saint Seiya. The movie was initially launched on the finish of April 2023 in Japan earlier than hitting choose theaters within the United States in early May. The movie facilities on Seiya, a avenue orphan who discovers he’s destined to guard a younger lady that could be a reincarnated goddess.
- Director
- Tomasz Baginski
- Distributor(s)
- Toei Company , Sony
- Cast
- Famke Janssen , Madison Iseman , Sean Bean , Mark Dacascos , Nick Stahl , Diego Tinoco , Caitlin Hutson , Mackenyu
- Runtime
- 112 Minutes
- Budget
- $60 Million
Knights of the Zodiac and One Piece had been launched across the identical time, they usually couldn’t have been extra completely different tasks. Apart from the truth that they had been each primarily based on extremely widespread anime properties and starred Mackenyu, there have been mainly no similarities between One Piece and Knights of the Zodiac. Whereas One Piece proved that live-action remakes can work below the suitable circumstances, Knights of the Zodiac repeated the errors made by Dragonball Evolution and different failed variations. As unimaginable as One Piece was, Knights of the Zodiac is a reminder that adapting anime remains to be very troublesome.
Netflix closely marketed
One Piece
and positioned the present as certainly one of its largest releases of 2023.
Of course, the expectations for Knights of the Zodiac and One Piece weren’t the identical. The live-action sequence primarily based on Eiichiro Oda’s record-breaking manga was meant to be an enormous undertaking for Netflix from the beginning, with every episode having a big funds to carry the story to life. Netflix closely marketed One Piece and positioned the present as certainly one of its largest releases of 2023. Knights of the Zodiac, alternatively, had a manufacturing funds of $60 million, and its theatrical launch was not even confirmed till a lot later.
One Piece & Knights Of The Zodiac Show The Best & Worst Of Live-Action Anime
One Piece Is Now The Benchmark For Anime Adaptations
One Piece and Knights of the Zodiac are excessive opposites in relation to Hollywood live-action anime variations. After Dragonball Evolution, it appeared like no live-action undertaking primarily based on a well-liked manga was ever going to work. Apart from variations of lesser-known titles equivalent to Speed Racer or Edge of Tomorrow, live-action variations continued to disappoint. Even main releases like Ghost within the Shell (2017), Death Note (2017), and Cowboy Bebop did not stay as much as their respective supply supplies.
That stated, One Piece’s success made it clear that even probably the most fantastical anime could be translated into different media if handled fastidiously and with plenty of respect. Not solely was Oda an government producer on the Netflix present, however your entire artistic staff made positive to remain as truthful to the supply materials as potential. It is troublesome to guage Knights of the Zodiac’s artistic selections when a lot in regards to the undertaking already appeared worrying even earlier than a trailer was launched. The live-action Saint Seiya film arguably by no means had an opportunity.
One Piece (Live-Action)
3.5
Based on the favored manga/anime sequence, One Piece is a live-action Netflix adaptation of the story from Eiichiro Oda. The present follows the exploits of a band of pirates, the Straw Hats, led by the energetic and adventure-loving Monkey D. Luffy. Luffy is a younger man cursed with unusual powers after by accident consuming a mysterious fruit. With his mates Zoro, Nami, Usopp, and Sanji, Luffy will head throughout the huge ocean to seek out the legendary treasure, the One Piece.
- Cast
- Iñaki Godoy , Mackenyu , Emily Rudd , Jacob Romero Gibson , Taz Skylar
- Release Date
- August 31, 2023
- Seasons
- 1
