An picture from “The Price of Passion” Sustainability and shortage of alternative have been predominant challenges of a documentary profession for the reason that early days of the shape, however sustaining psychological well being has been a major one as properly. Launched in 2021 by a bunch of documentary filmmakers and mental-health professionals, DocuMentality developed out of a collection of revelatory shows and conversations–first at IDA’s Getting Real convention in 2018, then a yr later, over the course of a two-week on-line dialogue entitled Mental Health and the Documentary Business, hosted by long-running international discussion board The D-Word. This previous May, the DocuMentality crew launched its first report: The Price of Passion: How Our Love for Documentary Filmmaking Impacts Our Mental Health, the product of a yr of analysis drawing upon the testimonials of individuals in 21 focus teams throughout three international locations: the US, the UK and Canada.
The report reveals a litany of all-too-familiar situations affecting the documentary discipline, together with problematic energy dynamics between filmmaking groups and funders, distributors, exhibitors and commissioning editors; stress inside filmmaking groups; obligation of look after individuals and audiences; family-work steadiness; isolation and loneliness; lack of assets to handle psychological well being; and identity-specific experiences amongst marginalized constituencies.
The genesis of the report will be traced again to 2019, when American documentary filmmaker Andrew Berends (The Blood of my Brother, When Adnan Comes Home) died by suicide–a tragedy that spurred The D-Word group into motion. D-Word co-hosts Doug Block, Marjan Safinia, Erica Ginsberg and Peter Gerrard reached out to Edinburgh, Scotland-based filmmaker-turned-psychotherapist Rebecca Day to average a two-week-long discussion board on psychological well being. A decade or so into her filmmaking profession, having witnessed the psychological and emotional toll such a profession path can take, Day launched a parallel profession as a psychotherapist, and, following years of coaching, began Film in Mind in 2018 to function a psychotherapeutic infrastructure for the documentary group within the UK.
Early on within the session, one participant disclosed a suicide try. “We were all holding our breath for a minute,” Safinia recollects, “but what cascaded out of that was this space of honesty. There’s nothing radical or new about this topic. Anyone who’s been doing this work has been suffering from mental health challenges related to it for a very long time…What we were hoping to do was normalize this as an occupational hazard. If we can normalize talking about it, without it being a ding on your professional capacity, it would really help us move the ball forward.”
The D-Word crew linked Day with Malikkah Rollins, DOC NYC’s director of business and schooling, who has years of expertise as a licensed social employee and psychological well being advocate, and in 2021 DocuMentality was born. Over the following couple of years, the DocuMentality crew made shows at festivals and documentary occasions all over the world. (These had been undertaken in partnership with Documentary Organization of Canada, Documentary Film Council and Scottish Documentary Institute, and with funding from American Documentary/POV, Screen Scotland, British Film Institute, Doc Society and Canada Media Fund.) Through this work, Day and Rollins developed the rules and analysis template in 2022 and 2023 that may result in The Price of Passion.
Rollins recollects how struck she was, when she first entered the documentary discipline a number of years in the past, by how “deeply systemic and dysfunctional so many issues are that impact documentary filmmakers when it comes to their mental health and well-being that are not addressed…Filmmakers have to carry tremendous responsibility…with zero training when it comes to mental-health issues.”
As lead facilitators, Day and Rollins labored with a mental-health researcher to craft the format and tips for the focus-group periods that may function the muse for the research. “We wanted to look internally at filmmakers’ mental health and well-being, but also, what were the external forces coming at them that made their lives really difficult?” Rollins explains. “That was really important for us, that we had someone guiding us,” Day provides, in a separate video name. “Despite our own mental-health training, we needed that independent voice.”
In imagining the main focus teams, Day and Rollins had been additionally intent on accommodating identity-specific experiences, and, accordingly, creating the chance for individuals to align themselves with their respective identities. “That was about creating safe spaces,” Day explains. “So it was really intentional, just thinking about what would each group need to feel as comfortable as possible in sharing what we’re asking them to share with us.”
“We didn’t choose the groups for them,“ Rollins adds, “but they had the option to be in groups of BIPOC filmmakers, women-identified filmmakers, filmmakers who identified as having a disability, Indigenous filmmakers, French-speaking, etc. We also chose facilitators who reflected those identities.”
As Day and Rollins be aware, the dynamics with respect to identification had been noticeably totally different among the many UK, US and Canadian focus teams. “We [in the UK] have a deep colonial past to reckon with,” Day factors out. “We are seeing changes, but a lot of people are saying that this industry still doesn’t feel like a safe place for filmmakers of color, filmmakers with disabilities and the queer filmmaking community. There’s a lot of work in different pockets happening that are trying to build these communities up, but that often happens on the fringes of the industry; it’s not happening so readily within the industry.”
Rollins famous a stark distinction when it comes to systemic racism within the UK versus the US. “Some of the systems of oppression in the UK are quite different than I know of here,” she observes. “There seemed to be so few people of color who work in the documentary funding world in the UK who had any positions of power…So that was surprising, just to hear about their own system and how deeply oppressed they felt. Some of the racism was way more blatant than you tend to hear about in America.”
While the anecdotal findings of The Price of Passion didn’t yield beautiful revelations in regards to the state of the sector when it comes to psychological wellness, the report can function a touchstone for deeper inquiry and additional motion.
Filmmakers who participated within the challenge provided a strong litany of optimistic pathways for making a extra accommodating ecosystem. Many of those suggestions centered across the energy dynamics between gatekeepers–funders, commissioners, distributors–and filmmakers. Funding shortage exacerbates this imbalance, and even these initiatives that handle to safe funding face problems with inventive management amid the preeminence of market-driven economics. The individuals referred to as for transparency and accountability on the funding aspect and a better say-so on the creator aspect within the DEI composition of the gatekeeping equipment.
Participants additionally really useful line gadgets for psychological well being assist in manufacturing budgets. This assist might take the type of on-call therapists, trauma specialists, or conflict-resolution managers; psychological well being coaching periods for filmmakers; and scheduled time for check-ins, debriefs and decompression.
Safinia attests, “People are reaching out, saying, ‘How do we build the findings and recommendation from this report into our fellowship?’ We don’t have all the answers for that, but the very fact that organizations are now reaching out to us to collaboratively figure out ways that it can fit into their work means that the work has had the success that we wanted, which is to make this something that is not taboo. We’re trying to create the conditions in which we can support people to come up with solutions that make sense in their individual spaces.”
“A big part of what we’re trying to do,” Block provides, ”apart from destigmatizing the entire dialog round psychological well being and well-being, is to get it on the radar of the business and make organizations perceive that is actually necessary and must be thought-about.”
In the months because it was revealed, The Price of Passion has caught the eye of not solely the documentary ecosystem, however the mental-wellness group as properly. Rollins and Day have each fielded calls from many mental-health professionals expressing curiosity in getting extra concerned. “I think the impact is incredible gratitude,” Rollins asserts. “It’s now part of the general culture to talk much more about mental health and well-being, and to use our report hopefully as a launching point. But a report is part one, like a 30,000 foot view. Part two to part 100 is how to actually take the education and the learning and deepen it [for] filmmakers so they’re living it every day of their lives.”
Two months after The Price of Passion was launched, Day developed a Film Supervision initiative at Film in Mind As a part of this initiative, a corps of therapeutic practitioners (together with Rollins)–all of whom have some background in documentary–will work with filmmaking groups to course of the emotional, moral and inventive quandaries inherent of their initiatives. According to Rollins, “We are getting many more requests for information about trauma-informed filmmaking: what that means, what goes into it, how they can be more cognizant, more aware. They really want help and guidance. And I think this is a beginning. There’s much, much more to do. What’s important now, after the report, is to put specific practices into place to make the learning real for filmmakers.”
“Film supervision is based on a support model that exists in the therapeutic world,” Day explains. “It’s really looking at a filmmaker’s duty of care and responsibilities to their participants and to audiences, and we’re working with them on ethical dilemmas, accountability, their awareness as a filmmaker—what they bring, the power dynamics, all of those things that come into the filmmaking conversation. It’s a collaborative and guided relationship with the filmmaker, and very film-focused and career-focused.”
The DocuMentality crew has additionally spotlighted ethics as a key part in addressing psychological well being. “I think there’s a real overlap between ethics and mental health and well-being,” Rollins asserts. “So many filmmakers struggle with ethical dilemmas that cause them tremendous fear and grief and isolation and confusion. I really am excited about digging deep into those ethical dilemmas, and bringing that hopefully to industry funders and other institutions that can really provide training to not just filmmakers, but also people who fund films, people who purchase films. It is such a thorny area, and one where true harm can be done.”
The conversations round ethics and documentary filmmaking have most acutely centered round filmmaker-participant relationships. Questions of compensation, boundary-setting, and obligation of care as soon as the movie has been launched have come to the forefront lately, due to initiatives just like the Documentary Accountability Working Group (DAWG), Peace Is Loud (with whom Rollins and Day have additionally labored), and Documentary Participants Empowerment Alliance, which developed from Jennifer Tiexiera and Camilla Hall’s 2022 documentary Subject. One director within the report shared, “I feel I am opening the gates to criticism for a vulnerable person, making public the most salacious private aspects of their lives. We’re not supported to help them think through what that will mean. In fact, the industry as a whole actually wants to disregard that because it’s kind of directly threatening to an unencumbered release of a film.”
Other subsequent steps—contingent on funding, in fact—that the DocuMentality crew hopes to pursue embody constructing bridges with The Dart Center for Journalism & Trauma at Columbia Journalism School, with whom DocuMentality has had preliminary conversations; compiling and posting a listing of therapists; and testing out partnerships with movie colleges. Day has observed a rising development of filmmakers exploring psychotherapy as a parallel career. “I get approached by filmmakers-turned-therapists at least once a month,” she maintains. “There are a lot of people who are in their training right now. I think in five years to come, we could probably have a database of therapists in the hundreds, who all have filmmaking experience.”
“A lot of it is about raising awareness,” Day notes. “It’s about really validating experiences for filmmakers, so they can use that also as support, as guidance, as motivation for how to do things differently, how to advocate for themselves and ask for things. It’s a catalyst for the next steps, which is opening that up to the wider industry and doing more research, but also bringing people together.”
Tom White is a Los Angeles-based author and editor.
